7 Signs Your Import File Wouldn't Hold Up in a CBSA Verification

A CBSA trade compliance verification is a review of past entries to check whether you declared tariff classification, value for duty and origin correctly. CBSA calls it a verification. Most importers call it a customs audit. Same thing.

Most importers find out how good their records are on the worst possible day: the day a CBSA letter asks for them.


By then it's too late to build the file properly. You're reconstructing it under a deadline, and every gap you find is a gap CBSA can find too.


The pressure is rising. In July 2026, CBSA moved three more items onto its targeted verification priorities list, bringing it to 12 targets, up from nine in January (PwC Canada, Tax Insights: CBSA releases July 2026 trade compliance verification priorities, August 2026). Two of the three new additions relate to surtax orders. And verifications aren't only priority-driven. CBSA also selects importers at random.


So the useful question isn't "will we get picked?" It's "if we did, what would they find?" Below are seven signs your file would struggle, and what to fix first.


Key Takeaways


  • Canadian importers must keep commercial import records for six years (Imported Goods Records Regulations, s. 2).

  • Once you have "reason to believe" an entry is wrong, you have 90 days to correct it, reaching back up to four years (Customs Act, s. 32.2).

  • Most verification problems are documentation problems, not bad faith. They're fixable before CBSA asks.

First, what is a CBSA verification?

A CBSA trade compliance verification is a review of past entries to check whether you declared tariff classification, value for duty and origin correctly. CBSA calls it a verification. Most importers call it a customs audit. Same thing.


It usually starts with a letter or questionnaire. According to CBSA Memorandum D11-6-8, that letter sets out the scope, the period being reviewed and the documents CBSA wants. Officers can also visit your premises, use information they already hold (like your B3s or CARM data) and send goods for lab analysis.


Before a full verification, you might get a lighter touch. CBSA uses compliance validation letters, which ask for supporting information within 30 days where it suspects non-compliance (EY, CBSA issues July 2025 trade compliance verification list, July 2025). Thirty days sounds like plenty. It isn't, if your records live in five inboxes.


If you want to see what CBSA is targeting this year, our breakdown of CBSA trade verification priorities for 2026 covers the list. This post is about the other half: whether your file is ready.

Sign 1: You can't pull a complete entry package in under an hour

Here's a simple test. Pick any commercial entry from 18 months ago. Now try to pull together:


  • the commercial invoice and any later price adjustments

  • the B3 or CARM accounting declaration

  • the bill of lading or waybill

  • the purchase order and proof of payment

  • origin documents, if you claimed a preference

  • anything showing where the goods went after release


If that takes an afternoon of emailing your broker, your freight forwarder and accounting, you have a problem.


The law is specific. Importers must keep records on the origin, marking, purchase, importation, costs, value, payment and disposal of commercial goods for six years after importation (Imported Goods Records Regulations, SOR/86-1011, s. 2(1)). And under CBSA Memorandum D17-1-21, those records must be kept in a way that lets an officer do detailed audits. Keeping them outside Canada needs CBSA's written authorization.


Missing records cost more than a penalty. Failing to keep records can also lead to preferential tariff treatment being denied (Omnitrans, Record Keeping Obligations). That can turn a duty-free CUSMA entry into a dutiable one, years after the fact.


The 60-minute rule: If you can't assemble one full entry package in an hour, assume a 30-day CBSA request would take you most of the month. Fix the filing system before you fix anything else.

Sign 2: Your HS codes came from the supplier, and nobody checked

Ask how a product got its tariff classification. If the answer is "the supplier put it on the invoice" or "it's always been that code," that's a weak spot.


Suppliers often classify goods for their country's tariff, not Canada's. The first six digits of the HS code are shared internationally. The last four are Canadian, and that's where duty rates and surtax exposure often change.


What CBSA wants to see is reasoning. That means a short note for each main product saying what it is, what it's made of, what it does, and why it fits the heading you chose. If you've ever received a CBSA ruling or an advance ruling, that belongs on file too.


Classification is a standing item on CBSA's verification lists. EY's July 2026 summary confirms tariff classification, valuation and origin remain the three core verification areas (EY, CBSA issues July 2026 trade compliance verification list update, July 2026). If CBSA reclassifies one product, it can re-determine every entry of that product going back up to four years (CBSA Memorandum D11-6-10).



Sign 3: The value you declared isn't what you actually paid

Value for duty usually starts with the price paid. The trouble is that the price on the invoice is often not the final price.


Watch for these:


  • Post-import price changes. Year-end rebates, retroactive price increases, or credit notes that change what you really paid.

  • Payments that never touch the invoice. Royalties, licence fees, or tooling and moulds you supplied to the manufacturer (customs calls these "assists").

  • Related-party pricing. If you buy from a parent or sister company, CBSA may ask whether the relationship influenced the price.

  • Freight and insurance confusion. Canada values goods at the point of direct shipment, so how your Incoterms split costs matters.


Here's the part that catches people. Your accounting team may adjust prices in the ledger and never tell your broker. CBSA can see the payment trail. If the ledger says one thing and the B3 says another, the gap is what a verification will focus on.


This is a common place where nobody did anything wrong on purpose. Finance and customs just never talked.


Sign 4: You claim CUSMA (or CETA) but can't show proof of origin

Claiming a preferential tariff saves real money. It also creates a duty to back it up.


If you claim CUSMA, CETA, CPTPP or another agreement, you need the origin certification on file when you claim it, not after CBSA asks. A certification that's expired, incomplete or signed by someone who can't actually support it won't help you.


Origin is one of the three core verification areas. In 2026, CBSA also put origin verifications under free trade agreements on its priorities list, including CUSMA, CETA and the Canada-UK agreement (GHY International, CBSA Publishes January 2026 Trade Compliance Verification Priorities, January 2026).


A practical check: for your top five preferential-claim products, could your supplier explain why the goods qualify? Which rule of origin applies, and what's the tariff shift or regional value content? If they can't, your certificate is only as strong as their guess.


If you import UK goods, the new CPUKT option adds another layer to get right. See our guide to the Canada-UK CPTPP tariff treatment.

Sign 5: You have surtax exposure and no origin trail

Surtaxes are the newest pressure point, and many importers haven't caught up.


Canada's US surtax took effect on September 8, 2026. It sits on top of earlier surtax orders on goods from China and on certain steel and aluminum products. Surtax liability depends on origin. So does the defence.


PwC's July 2026 review notes that surtax-related verifications are now on CBSA's priorities list alongside trade agreement origin checks (PwC Canada, August 2026). That means CBSA will be asking: where were these goods actually made, and how do you know?


Signs you're exposed:


  • You buy from a US distributor and assume the goods are US-origin (or assume they aren't).

  • You declared goods as non-US origin but have nothing beyond the invoice to prove it.

  • You relied on the in-transit exemption for September 8 shipments but didn't keep the shipping evidence.


Our 20 questions on the US surtax, CARM and customs value covers the declaration side. For verification, the rule is simple: if origin changes what you owe, keep proof of origin.

Sign 6: You knew about an error and didn't correct it

This is the sign that turns a fixable problem into a penalty problem.


Under section 32.2 of the Customs Act, once you have "reason to believe" a declaration of origin, classification or value is wrong, you must correct it within 90 days. The obligation reaches back up to four years from when the goods were accounted for.


"Reason to believe" doesn't need to come from CBSA. CBSA Memorandum D11-6-6 lists the kinds of information that trigger it: a ruling on the same goods, a supplier's notice, an internal review, or a verification report on your own entries.


Here's the trap. The 90-day clock starts when you had the information, not when CBSA contacts you (Cole International, Why 'reason to believe' catches Canadian importers off guard, 2026). So that email from a supplier last spring saying "we got the origin wrong"? If it's sitting in someone's inbox with no correction filed, it's evidence against you.


A few points that matter:


  • Corrections that increase what you owe, or leave it unchanged, go through section 32.2 on a B2 adjustment request.

  • Corrections that lower your duty are refunds under section 74. They're not a 32.2 obligation and have their own deadlines.

  • If you've missed the 90 days, it still usually pays to correct. Ask early whether a voluntary disclosure makes sense.


Sign 7: Nobody owns customs compliance

Ask who in your company is responsible for customs. If the answer is "our broker," that's the last sign, and maybe the most important.


Your broker transmits entries on your behalf. But the importer of record is legally responsible for what's declared. If the broker used the wrong code because nobody told them the product changed, the reassessment still lands on you.


Files that hold up usually have:


  • a named internal owner for customs, even part-time

  • written product data (descriptions, materials, use) your broker classifies from

  • a regular review of a sample of entries against invoices

  • a record of what you told your broker, and when


None of this needs a large compliance team. It needs someone to own it and a paper trail showing they did.

How to check your file before CBSA does

You don't need to wait for a letter to find out where you stand. Start small:


  1. Pick 10 entries from the past two years, weighted toward your highest-duty products.

  2. Rebuild each entry package using the Sign 1 list. Note anything missing.

  3. Check classification reasoning for each product. Is it written down?

  4. Compare declared value against what accounting shows you actually paid.

  5. Confirm origin proof for every preference claim and anything with surtax exposure.

  6. Look for known errors that were never corrected, and note the date you found them.


If this turns up problems, that's useful. It's far better to find them yourself, on your schedule, than to read about them in a Detailed Adjustment Statement.


If you'd rather have someone experienced run the review with you, our customs audit support team can help you organize records, find the high-risk entries and decide what to correct first.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to keep import records in Canada?

Six years after the goods were imported. The Imported Goods Records Regulations require records on origin, marking, purchase, costs, value, payment and disposal of commercial goods. Records must stay in Canada unless CBSA authorizes another location in writing. Non-resident importers have the same obligation.

How does CBSA choose which importers to verify?

Two ways. CBSA selects some importers at random and targets others through its verification priorities list, which is updated during the year. By July 2026 the list had 12 targeted priorities, up from nine in January, with several tied to surtax orders (PwC Canada, 2026).

How far back can a CBSA verification go?

Generally four years. Under section 59 of the Customs Act, CBSA can re-determine origin, classification or value for duty within four years of the original determination. Your own correction obligation under section 32.2 also reaches back up to four years from when goods were accounted for.

What is "reason to believe" and why does it matter?

It's the point where you have specific information that a declaration was wrong. A supplier notice, a ruling or an internal review can trigger it. From that date you have 90 days to correct affected entries under section 32.2 of the Customs Act, whether or not CBSA has contacted you.

Is my customs broker responsible if CBSA finds errors?

Usually not in the way importers hope. The importer of record is responsible for what's declared, even if a broker prepared the entry. That's why your file should show what product information you gave your broker and when. Brokers can help you respond, but liability for duties stays with you.

The bottom line

Most importers who struggle in a CBSA verification aren't hiding anything. Their records are scattered, their HS codes were inherited, their pricing changed after entry, and nobody connected the dots.


Every one of the seven signs above can be fixed before CBSA asks. Start with Sign 1. If you can't build a complete entry package quickly, nothing else in your file will matter much.