How Do You Switch Customs Brokers in Canada Safely?

|

Unhappy with your customs broker? You're not locked in. Since CARM, the link between you and your broker lives in your own CARM Client Portal account, and you control it. That makes switching simpler than most importers expect.


It also makes it easier to get wrong. Cut off the old broker too early and in-flight shipments can't be finally accounted for. Forget your records and you carry the gap for years. This guide walks through the order that keeps goods moving, plus the obligations that stay with you no matter who files your entries.


Key Takeaways


  • Only your CARM Business Account Manager can approve or end a broker's access (CBSA, CARM delegation user guide).

  • Don't expire the old broker until every released shipment has final accounting.

  • You must keep import records for six years and correct errors for four, whoever your broker is.

Can You Switch Customs Brokers at Any Time?

Yes. Under CARM, your broker acts through a business relationship you approve in the CARM Client Portal. The CBSA's delegation user guide says only an importer's Business Account Manager can set up or manage these relationships. You can add a new broker or expire an old one whenever you choose.


What stops most importers isn't the CBSA. It's the contract with the current broker. Read it before you give notice. Look for:


  • Notice period. Many agency agreements require written notice a set number of days before termination.

  • Open invoices. Brokers often hold disbursements for duties they paid on your behalf. Settle these first.

  • Record custody. Check whether the broker keeps copies of your entries and how you get them back.


There's one more reason switching got easier. Before CARM, many importers relied on the broker's security to get goods released before paying duty. That's over. CBSA Customs Notice 24-27 says importers who want release prior to payment must post their own financial security in the portal.


In 2026, the last link to the old model ended. The CBSA's consultation report on broker business numbers says a temporary measure let importers use a broker's business number until importer of record changes took effect on January 1, 2026. Now your registration, security and delegation all sit in your own account. A broker switch no longer means rebuilding your release privileges from scratch.

What Changes in the CARM Client Portal When You Switch?

The portal is where the switch actually happens. According to the CBSA's user guide, the new broker sends a relationship request using your business number. Your Business Account Manager then approves it and chooses the access type: all programs or specific programs.


Here's what each side does.

What the new broker does

  1. Searches for your business number in the portal.

  2. Sends a business relationship request with a short justification.

What you do

  1. Log in as Business Account Manager and open Manage my business relationships.

  2. Find the request under Received requests.

  3. Pick the access type. "All programs" gives the broker near-full access to your business account. "Specific programs" limits it to chosen program accounts.

  4. Set visibility rules. These control which transactions the broker can see, including ones filed by you or by other providers.

  5. Approve. The relationship is live.


You can edit the expiry date, visibility and access type later. That expiry date matters more than it looks, as the next section explains.


A detail worth knowing: when you expire a relationship, the CBSA guide says the broker's staff lose all access at once. If you re-establish it later, the old configuration doesn't come back. You'll have to set it up again.


Our take: The riskiest part of a switch is the order of steps, not the paperwork. It's tempting to expire the old broker the day you sign with the new one. The safer pattern is a short overlap where both brokers have access.

Why Shouldn't You Remove Your Old Broker Right Away?

Because they may still owe CBSA paperwork for your shipments. CBSA Customs Notice 25-16 describes cases where a broker obtained release of goods but couldn't submit final accounting because the importer hadn't completed delegation of authority. Remove access early and you create that exact gap.


Missing final accounting isn't a small issue. The same notice says the CBSA is issuing late accounting penalties for transactions with no final accounting, then assessing duties, taxes and interest. Unpaid amounts can be referred to the Canada Revenue Agency for collection.


So plan an overlap window:


  • Before the switch date, tell the old broker the last shipment they'll handle.

  • After that shipment releases, confirm they've submitted the Commercial Accounting Declaration (CAD) for every release.

  • Then expire their relationship in the portal.


Setting the old broker's expiry date in advance helps. It puts a hard stop on access without a manual step you might forget.


Isn't it simpler to run both brokers forever? Not really. Two brokers with full visibility means two parties seeing your data and more chance of a duplicate filing. Keep the overlap short and deliberate.

Which Records Should You Collect Before You Leave?

All of them, because the legal duty to keep records is yours, not your broker's. CBSA Memorandum D17-1-21 says importers must keep records for six years after importing commercial goods. A broker or other agent can hold them for you, but the importer stays responsible for the legal requirements.


Ask your outgoing broker for a full export of:


  • Commercial Accounting Declarations and any older B3s for the past six years

  • Commercial invoices, bills of lading and proof of payment

  • Certificates or proof of origin used to claim CUSMA, CETA or CPTPP rates

  • Tariff classification rulings and any classification notes they relied on

  • Adjustment requests, refund claims and detailed adjustment statements

  • Correspondence with the CBSA, including audits or verifications


Store it somewhere you control. A shared drive organised by year and transaction number works fine.


If a non-resident importer had the old broker holding records in Canada, check that arrangement too. D17-1-21 says this needs written authorization through the CARM portal and an Agreement to Maintain Records (form BSF900). Moving records to a new agent means updating that paperwork.

What Liabilities Stay With You After You Switch?

Your correction duty does. CBSA Memorandum D11-6-6 says an importer must correct origin, tariff classification or value for duty within 90 days of having reason to believe a declaration is wrong. That obligation runs for four years after the goods are accounted for.


That's why a switch is a good moment for a review. A new broker looking at your file with fresh eyes may spot misclassified products or a valuation method nobody questioned. If they do, the 90-day clock starts once you have reason to believe there's an error. Waiting doesn't make it go away. It only adds interest and penalty exposure.


How long your customs obligations last after a broker switch


How long your obligations last (in months) Correct an error ~3 months (90 days) Correction window 48 months (4 years) Keep records 72 months (6 years) Sources: CBSA Memorandum D11-6-6; CBSA Memorandum D17-1-21 Obligations that stay with the importer after switching brokers. Sources: CBSA Memoranda D11-6-6 and D17-1-21. Three things carry over no matter who files your next entry:


  • Duties and taxes owed on past entries.

  • Corrections for errors on any entry still inside the four-year window.

  • Audit exposure. A CBSA verification can reach back across both brokers' work.

The 7-Step Checklist to Switch Customs Brokers

Here's the full process in order. It assumes you're already registered in CARM with your own release prior to payment security, as CBSA Customs Notice 24-27 requires for importers who want release before paying duties.


  1. Review your current agreement. Note the notice period, open invoices and how records are returned.

  2. Choose and sign with the new broker. They'll ask for a signed agency agreement, sometimes called a power of attorney.

  3. Share your product data. Give them your product list, HS codes, supplier details and any rulings so they can set up your profile before the first shipment.

  4. Approve the new broker in CARM. Accept their relationship request and set access and visibility.

  5. Pick a cut-over shipment. Tell your carriers, freight forwarders and suppliers which broker to notify from that date.

  6. Close out the old broker. Confirm final accounting is done for every release, settle invoices and collect six years of records.

  7. Expire the old relationship. End their access in the portal, then check no other users or programs still list them.


Step 5 is the one people skip. If your freight forwarder still sends arrival notices to the old broker, your goods sit while two offices sort it out.

How Do You Know It's Time to Switch?

Most importers switch for one of a few reasons, and none of them should be ignored for long. The cost of a weak broker shows up later, when the CBSA reassesses entries filed over the past four years under the correction window in Memorandum D11-6-6.


Watch for these signs:


  • Slow or no answers when a shipment is held.

  • Surprise reassessments or penalties you didn't see coming.

  • No advice. Your broker files entries but never suggests a free trade agreement claim or a duty saving.

  • CARM confusion. They can't explain your statement of account or your security.

  • Missed rule changes. In September 2026, for example, importers needed new surtax codes on the CAD. Did your broker warn you first?


If two or more of these sound familiar, it's worth getting a second opinion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I have two customs brokers at the same time?

Yes. The CBSA's CARM delegation guide describes separate relationships with customs brokers and trade consultants, and nothing in it limits you to one. Some importers use one broker for courier shipments and another for freight. Use visibility settings so each broker sees only what it needs.

Does switching brokers affect my release prior to payment security?

It shouldn't. Under CBSA Customs Notice 24-27, importers who want release prior to payment must post their own financial security in the CARM portal. Because the security is tied to your business account rather than the broker's, changing brokers doesn't remove it. Confirm it's active before your first shipment with the new broker.

Who is responsible for mistakes my old broker made?

You are, in most cases. CBSA Memorandum D11-6-6 makes the importer responsible for correcting origin, classification or value errors within 90 days of having reason to believe they exist, for four years after accounting. Your agreement with the old broker may give you recourse against them separately.

How long does it take to switch customs brokers?

The portal step takes minutes once your Business Account Manager approves the request. The full switch usually depends on your old contract's notice period and how long final accounting takes on in-flight shipments. Plan a short overlap rather than a same-day cut-over.

Do I need to tell the CBSA I'm changing brokers?

Generally not as a separate step. The CBSA's delegation user guide treats the broker relationship as something you approve or expire in the CARM Client Portal, so that's where the change happens. Do tell your carriers and freight forwarders, though, so arrival notices go to the right broker.

Ready to Switch? Start With a Free File Review

Switching customs brokers comes down to four things:


  • Approve the new broker in CARM before the old one leaves.

  • Keep a short overlap until every released shipment has final accounting.

  • Collect six years of records, because they're your responsibility.

  • Use the switch to check past entries, since corrections are yours for four years.


uCustoms handles the CARM setup, the cut-over plan and a review of your recent entries, so the switch doesn't cost you a held shipment.