Surtax Order Audits in 2026: Why CBSA Is Checking Your Chapter 99 Claims
|
CBSA found errors in 66% of surtax audits in 2026. Learn which surtax orders a Chapter 99 claim exempts you from, and which it doesn’t
Few importers paid much attention to Chapter 99 of the Customs Tariff. Their broker put a code in the tariff field, duty dropped to zero, and nobody looked at it again.
That's changing. One of CBSA's 2026 verification priorities is built around Chapter 99. CBSA wants to know whether importers applied the 25% surtax under the Steel Goods and Aluminum Goods Surtax Order to steel melted and poured in China, or aluminum smelted and cast there, when those goods were classified under Chapter 99 (GHY International, October 2026 update).
Only 23 companies are targeted under that priority, so it's a small one. The problem it points to is much bigger. Every surtax order handles Chapter 99 in its own way, and a lot of import files run on one rule: "if it's in Chapter 99, there's no surtax." That rule holds for some orders and fails for others.
Key Takeaways
In 2026, CBSA found errors in 345 of 523 closed surtax verifications, about 66%, with $41.25 million assessed (GHY International, October 2026 update).
A Chapter 99 classification exempts goods from the US surtax orders, with listed exceptions. It doesn't exempt them from the Steel Goods and Aluminum Goods, Steel Derivative Goods or China EV orders.
If a Chapter 99 end-use claim fails, you can owe the regular duty and a surtax the claim was hiding.
What is a surtax order audit?
A surtax order audit is a CBSA trade compliance verification that checks whether you declared and paid a surtax correctly. That means the right order, the right rate, the right origin and the right value for duty. Six surtax orders have published results in CBSA's 2026 rounds, and the error rates are high across most of them.
Source: GHY International, CBSA Releases October 2026 Trade Compliance Verification Priorities and Results, summarizing CBSA's October 30, 2026 update. Assessed revenue in these rounds includes duties, GST, interest and penalties.
The Steel Derivative Goods Surtax Order is on the list too, but CBSA hasn't published results for it yet.
Our earlier post on what the 2026 error rates say about your risk covers the whole list, surtax and otherwise. If you need help mapping your own imports against the CBSA verification priorities 2026 list, we do that too. This post stays on one narrow question: where does Chapter 99 fit?
What is Chapter 99, and why does it matter for surtax?
Chapter 99 holds special classification provisions. They reduce or remove customs duty depending on how the goods are used or why they qualify. You still classify the goods under Chapters 1 to 97 first. The Chapter 99 item goes in the tariff code field of the CARM accounting declaration, next to the normal 10-digit classification (Cole International, How classification under Chapter 99 of Canada's Customs Tariff works).
Many Chapter 99 items are conditional relief items. They work along the lines of "for use in" making some other product. CBSA lets you claim the relief when you account for the goods, as long as the goods fit the item, can meet its conditions, and you reasonably expect those conditions to be met. CBSA's Memorandum D11-8-5 goes further: claim it without that reasonable expectation and you've made a false declaration.
Chapter 99 relieves customs duty. Surtax is a separate charge. Whether Chapter 99 also relieves surtax depends only on the wording of the surtax order, and the orders don't agree with each other.
Does a Chapter 99 classification exempt goods from surtax?
Sometimes. Here's how the main orders treat it, based on CBSA's customs notices for each one.
Order schedules change, so check the current version of each order before you rely on this table.
The pattern is fairly clear once it's laid out side by side. Canada's counter-surtaxes on US goods generally leave Chapter 99 alone, with a short list of carve-outs. The steel, aluminum and China-focused orders mostly don't care about Chapter 99 at all. So a blanket rule in your ERP or your broker's client profile that says "Chapter 99 means no surtax" will be right on some lines and wrong on others. From the way CBSA describes the risk, that's the mistake this priority is looking for.
The 2026 orders keep adding to this. The US Surtax Order (2026) came in on September 8 with rates of 15%, 25% and 50% (CN 26-23). Newer orders, like the 2026 wood cabinet and vanity order, also have their own Chapter 99 wording. Every new order is one more rule to check.
What does CBSA look at in a Chapter 99 tariff item audit?
In practice, a Chapter 99 tariff item audit tends to come down to two questions.
Did the goods qualify for the Chapter 99 item in the first place? For conditional relief items, the answer sits in your end-use records. Section 3 of the Imported Goods Records Regulations requires a certificate or other record proving how the goods were actually used. Under CBSA Memorandum D11-8-6, that record has to:
identify the importation, such as the transaction number and the Chapter 99 tariff item
give the user's name, address and occupation
state the actual use of the goods
D11-8-6 also includes a sample attestation in its appendix, which is a reasonable template to work from.
Distributors and wholesalers have the hardest time here. If you import under an end-use item and then sell to customers, the proof of use has to come from your customers. AlCircle's coverage of the July 2026 priorities makes this point directly: importers who never collected end-use certificates from customers can struggle to support the claim later.
Then there's diversion. If goods imported under a conditional relief item end up used for something else, subsection 32.2(6) of the Customs Act treats that as an incorrect tariff classification. Under D11-8-5, a later owner has 90 days to tell their supplier about a diversion, and the importer then has 90 days to correct the declaration. Selling the goods on without the required paperwork counts as failing the conditions of relief.
If the goods did qualify, was surtax still owed? For the steel and aluminum orders, that means proving where the metal was melted and poured or smelted and cast. For the US orders, it means proving origin and checking that the Chapter 99 item isn't on the order's exception list. And for every order, the surtax is calculated on value for duty, so a wrong value means a wrong surtax.
When the documents aren't there, CBSA's surtax notices let it re-calculate the surtax owing. Expect the worst-case version of that calculation.
Why the Chapter 99 numbers look small, and why that's misleading
On paper, the Chapter 99 priority is the smallest surtax line. Eight errors and $265,771 assessed, or about $33,000 per error. The US Surtax Order (2025-1) works out to roughly $96,500 per error.
We don't read that as a reason to relax. The priority is small because it's narrow: one order, goods that are both Chapter 99 and China-melted steel or aluminum. The underlying mistake isn't narrow. It's a classification habit, and habits get copied across every line where someone applied the same rule.
There's also a compounding problem the per-error average hides. Say your Chapter 99 end-use claim fails on goods covered by one of the US orders. Losing Chapter 99 doesn't only bring back the regular customs duty. It also takes away the Chapter 99 surtax exemption. One weak end-use file can turn into duty, surtax, interest and penalties on the same entry, reaching back up to four years.
What should you do if you've used Chapter 99 on surtax-exposed goods?
Start with the data, not the paperwork. A simple review looks like this:
Pull your Chapter 99 entries. Take 12 to 24 months of entries with a Chapter 99 tariff code. Flag any whose Chapters 1 to 97 classification appears in a surtax order schedule.
Match each line to its order. Use the table above to see whether that order exempts Chapter 99. Check the version of the order in force on the entry date. Some amendments apply retroactively.
Test the end-use file. For conditional relief items, check you have records that meet D11-8-6: the transaction, the user and the actual use. If you resell, check what your customers actually gave you.
Test the surtax facts. For steel and aluminum, look for melt-and-pour or smelt-and-cast evidence from the mill, not just the supplier's invoice. For US goods, look for proof of origin.
Act on what you find. Once you have reason to believe a declaration is wrong, section 32.2 gives you 90 days to correct it. Our checklist of 7 signs your import file wouldn't hold up covers how that clock works.
Ask about remission. Surtax relief outside the orders runs through remission. The Department of Finance administers the US Remission Framework, and the United States Surtax Remission Order (2025) still applies to goods that already qualified under it (CN 26-23). It's worth checking before you assume the surtax is final.
If a compliance validation letter or a verification notice has already arrived, the timelines get much shorter. That's where our surtax order audit and CBSA trade compliance verification team can help. We sort the entries, work out which errors are real, and decide what to correct first.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a surtax order audit?
It's a CBSA trade compliance verification focused on surtax. CBSA checks whether you applied the right surtax order and rate, on the right origin and value for duty. In 2026, CBSA found errors in about 66% of closed surtax verifications, with $41.25 million assessed across six orders.
Does Chapter 99 exempt my goods from surtax?
It depends on the order. The US surtax orders generally exempt Chapter 99 goods, except for tariff items listed in the order. The Steel Goods and Aluminum Goods, Steel Derivative Goods and China EV surtax orders apply even when goods are classified under Chapter 99.
What records do I need for a Chapter 99 end-use claim?
A certificate or record of actual use, kept under section 3 of the Imported Goods Records Regulations. CBSA Memorandum D11-8-6 says it must identify the importation and the tariff item, give the user's name, address and occupation, and state the actual use. If you resell the goods, this usually has to come from your customers.
What happens if goods imported under Chapter 99 are used for something else?
That's a diversion. Under subsection 32.2(6) of the Customs Act, it's treated as an incorrect tariff classification that must be corrected. A later owner has 90 days to tell the supplier, and the importer has 90 days from that notice to correct the declaration. Duty, and any surtax the claim had covered, may then be owed.
Is Chapter 99 on CBSA's 2026 verification priorities list?
Yes. Since the July 2026 update, CBSA has been checking whether importers applied the 25% Steel Goods and Aluminum Goods surtax to goods classified under Chapter 99. As of October 30, 2026, CBSA had closed 20 of 23 targeted cases and found errors in 8.
The bottom line
Chapter 99 is still a legitimate way to save duty. It just doesn't do one consistent thing for surtax. Depending on the order, it's either an exemption with exceptions or nothing at all.
If your import file treats every Chapter 99 line the same way, someone should check it order by order. It's much cheaper to do that yourself than to have CBSA do it in a verification.
Sources
GHY International, CBSA Releases October 2026 Trade Compliance Verification Priorities and Results (Updated), retrieved 2026-11-18, https://www.ghy.com/trade-compliance/cbsa-2026-trade-compliance-priorities/
CBSA, Trade compliance verifications, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/import/verification/menu-eng.html
GHY International, CBSA Updates United States Surtax Orders Including Steel, Aluminum and Motor Vehicles (Updated), retrieved 2026-11-18, https://www.ghy.com/trade-compliance/cbsa-updates-us-surtax-orders-including-steel-aluminum-and-motor-vehicles/
CBSA, Customs Notice 25-10: United States Surtax Order (2025-1) (updated), via CSCB, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://cscb.ca/en/article/updated-customs-notice-25-10-united-states-surtax-order-2025-1
CBSA, Customs Notice 25-11: United States Surtax Order (Steel and Aluminum 2025) (updated), via CSCB, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://cscb.ca/en/article/updated-customs-notice-25-11-united-states-surtax-order-steel-and-aluminum-2025-1
CBSA, Customs Notice 26-23: United States Surtax Order (2026), via CSCB, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://cscb.ca/en/article/customs-notice-26-23-united-states-surtax-order-2026
CBSA, Customs Notice 25-28: Steel Goods and Aluminum Goods Surtax Order (updated), via CSCB, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://cscb.ca/en/article/updated-customs-notice-25-28-steel-goods-and-aluminum-goods-surtax-order
CBSA, Customs Notice 25-33: Steel Derivative Goods Surtax Order (updated), via CSCB, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://cscb.ca/en/article/updated-customs-notice-25-33-steel-derivative-goods-surtax-order
CBSA, Customs Notice 24-32: China Surtax Order (2024) – Electric Vehicles (updated), via CSCB, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://cscb.ca/en/article/updated-customs-notice-24-32-china-surtax-order-2024-electric-vehicles-0
CBSA, Customs Notice 26-17: Certain Wood Cabinet and Vanity Goods Surtax Order, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/publications/cn-ad/cn26-17-eng.html
CBSA, Memorandum D11-8-5: Conditional Relief Tariff Items, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/publications/dm-md/d11/d11-8-5-eng.html
CBSA, Memorandum D11-8-6: Interpretation of Section 3 of the Imported Goods Records Regulations, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/publications/dm-md/d11/d11-8-6-eng.html
Cole International, How classification under Chapter 99 of Canada's Customs Tariff works, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://blog.coleintl.com/import-foundations/how-classification-under-chapter-99-of-canadas-customs-tariff-works
AlCircle, CBSA increases scrutiny of aluminium surtax exemptions under updated compliance priorities, August 2026, retrieved 2026-11-18, https://www.alcircle.com/news/cbsa-increases-scrutiny-of-aluminium-surtax-exemptions-under-updated-compliance-priorities-120672